I need help choosing between two colleges?

I really like two colleges that I've looked at Fordham University and College of New Jersey. They're both great schools and are just what I was looking for in a college. Fordham is a Roman Catholic college, and I am Catholic, so that's great. Even tough College of New Jersey isn't a Catholic college, it's in the suburbs rather than New York city; so it's a safer area and campus. The best thing about College of New Jersey is that my two best friends are going to Princeton University, so they'll only be twenty minutes away from me by car. I got accepted to both of these schools, and I need a second opinion?