R&P: Question for those of you that might have knowledge for this guitar problem?

It is hard to tell from the pictures, but they look almost exactly the same size with the same cutouts to fit the pickup, knobs, bridge, etc. Pickguards for Fenders are usually just plastic anyway, so if something needs to be shaved down a little it shouldn't be that difficult to customize. I don't know what the gold annodize is from if that is just paint or something else. I would order it, and if it doesn't fit, just send it back for a refund or exchange. Might want to consider more how your guitar sounds and less how it looks though.